To speak to a Licensed Insurance Agent, Call Now!


In the ever-evolving landscape of healthcare, choosing the right insurance plan is a critical decision. One option that has gained popularity is the High Deductible Health Plan (HDHP). In this comprehensive guide, we will delve into the world of HDHPs, exploring their advantages, disadvantages, costs, and how they stack up against other options like PPOs and HSAs. We aim to provide you with expert insights and answers to commonly asked questions, helping you make an informed decision about your healthcare coverage.

HDHP vs. PPO: What’s the Difference?

Have you ever wondered why there are so many acronyms for health plans? There are several letters! But consider it this way. It’s easier to say PPO than Preferred Provider Organization. Or HDHP as an alternative to a high-deductible health Plan. A good start would be to shorten the names. But to determine which is best for you, you need an explanation of HDHP vs. PPO.

What Is HDHP vs. PPO?

What is the HDHP?

High Deductible Health Plans (HDHPs) are a common alternative to PPOs as the most prevalent health insurance policy. In 2021, an HDHP had a deductible of at least $1,400 for a person or $2,800 for a family. There are a few distinguishing features of HDHPs.

  • HDHPs are characterized by larger deductibles, as their name implies.
  • Affordable premiums are a common benefit of high-deductible health plans (or monthly insurance plan costs).
  • To start an HSA, you must have coverage from a high-deductible health plan. 

What are PPOs?

Preferred Provider Organizations (PPOs) are the most often used health insurance choice. Selecting a PPO allows you to see doctors (even specialists) without a recommendation. To see a doctor who isn’t in your PPO’s network will require extra steps and cost more money. PPO plans’ premium tends to be greater than those for HDHPs, but deductibles are typically substantially lower. A health savings account (HSA) is not an option with a traditional PPO.

What is the HSA?

An HSA allows you to save aside money tax-free to pay for future medical bills. Investment options are available for the cash contributed to your HSA by both you and your employer. Your contributions can be used to lower your taxable income. because they come from your paycheck before taxes are taken out. You can take the money with you if you move jobs, and any withdrawals made for medical purposes are tax-free. While PPOs also provide flexible spending accounts (FSAs), HSAs give you much more leeway when carrying over monies.

The tax-free status of HSAs usually is the norm, but two states now deviate from the federal standard. HSA payments and realized capital gains are subject to state income taxation in New Jersey and California. Since most brokerages that process HSAs do not send out tax forms, taxpayers must take responsibility for reporting these profits themselves on their tax returns.

Advantages of HDHP Plan vs. PPO

The benefits of an HDHP include decreased rates. Moreover, your copayments and prescriptions will be lower if you visit a doctor or hospital.

However, with a PPO, you can go to a specialist without first consulting your PCP and worrying about whether they are in your plan’s network. Nonetheless, their prices will be higher.

When deciding between the two, you should consider your preferences and requirements for medical coverage. For instance, if you’re young and healthy, a high-deductible health plan (HDHP) may be a good option because of its cheap monthly premiums and relatively low out-of-pocket costs. However, the costs may accumulate if you or a family member has a long-term illness.

Advantages of PPO vs. HDHP

PPOs benefit those at risk of requiring additional medical attention due to a chronic ailment. This plan is the easiest way to get in to see a specialist quickly and easily. The PPO premiums are higher regardless of whether or not you choose a large deductible. Because of the possibility of starting a health savings account (HSA), HDHPs go by another name: HSA-qualified plans.

According to IRS regulations, a person or family can save a maximum amount of money each year. Even though HDHP members may have higher out-of-pocket costs, the cheaper premiums may more than makeup for the difference.

HDHP vs. PPO Calculator

It is helpful to familiarize yourself with the abovementioned terminology to understand better how your costs for each health insurance option are determined. It would help to calculate your annual healthcare costs before making a final decision. Even if a healthy, energetic person doesn’t anticipate high prices, they should nonetheless plan in case they get sick. Remember that with either an HDHP or a PPO, you should be able to receive preventative care at no cost to you.

Once you know how much money you’ll need to spend on healthcare, you can compare different plans by adding their monthly premiums and maximum out-of-pocket costs. This is the maximum amount you will be responsible for paying in a given year for medical expenses, assuming you receive care from a provider within your insurance’s network.

The next step is to familiarize yourself with the fundamentals of each health plan.

  • The monthly cost of maintaining health insurance coverage is known as the “premium.”
  • The yearly deductible is the healthcare costs you pay out of pocket before insurance. Health insurance coverage will begin after the deductible is met.
  • Once yearly out-of-pocket costs for covered services (not including premiums) reach the annual maximum, the insurance company will begin paying for all expenses.
  • To use with an HDHP, an HSA is a pre-tax A bank account for health. Balances in an HSA are kept from one year to the next.
  • FSA stands for “flexible spending account,” a tax-free way to pay for some out-of-pocket medical expenses. If you already have an HSA, you cannot use it; your contributions usually do not carry over.
  • A copayment, or “copay,” is a fixed sum you pay for medical treatment such as prescriptions, doctor visits, and other preventive services.
  • You’ll have to pay some of your medical bills after meeting your deductible. Some of your medical expenditures are known as “coinsurance.”

High Deductible Health Plan Versus PPO Cost Examples

For instance, a PPO plan with a $1,250 deductible and a $600 monthly premium is possible. A yearly premium of $600 multiplied by 12 months ($6,600) plus the deductible for out-of-pocket payments (not counting copays or coinsurance) is $8,450. However, in 2020, the maximum out-of-pocket expense for an individual on a group plan will be $8,150, and the maximum for a family will be $16,300. Your actual costs are less than or equal to this maximum.

The premium for an HDHP with a $3,000 deductible may be $400 per month. A yearly premium of $7,800 is reached by multiplying the $400/month cost by 12 months and then adding the $2,000/year deductible for out-of-pocket expenses. In 2020, high-deductible health plans (HDHPs) cannot charge more than $6,900 per person in out-of-pocket costs or $13,800 per family. As a result, your actual costs must be, at most, the cap on such expenses.

In the second scenario, the monthly premium is reduced by $200, resulting in an annual savings of $900 for medical treatment.

According to Beaton, the more cost-effective alternative is if the HDHP’s out-of-pocket costs are less than the PPO’s. But before you make that decision, check to see if your finances can support it. Do you have the cash to cover the $250 copay for an office visit, the $800 ER bill on the day you receive care, and so on until your deductible is met? It’s not a good idea to sign up for an HDHP if you don’t have the financial flexibility to meet the increased fees at the time of service.

Signing up for a PPO plan could be more cost-effective in the long run, even if the monthly payment is more significant. If you have done the math and determined that the HDHP will result in higher out-of-pocket costs, or if you are not ready to take a chance on having no medical emergencies during the year, you should look into another option.

Choosing a health insurance policy is a deeply personal process that includes consideration of numerous issues, such as:

  • The condition of your health
  • Your family’s wellbeing
  • Healthcare providers and experts’ inclinations for a high degree of adaptability
  • The state of your finances
  • Should you pay extra up front for comprehensive insurance protection, or not
  • Amounts that can be taken out of your HSA
  • Each plan’s maximum out-of-pocket cost

Consult with health insurance providers or your company’s human resources department if you still need assistance deciding which plan is right for you. Remember that you can only change your plan during open enrollment once a year or if your life circumstance changes (marriage or divorce, the birth of a child, etc.).

Differences in Cost Between High Deductible Health Plan vs PPO

The cost question can take one of three forms, depending on the exact plans at your disposal:

With a PPO, you could reduce your energy use.

With a high-deductible health plan, you can cut costs significantly.

Both may be around the same price in various years or circumstances.

Let’s examine some specifics to understand the typical differences between HDHP and PPO plans.

You are at the prime of your life, both physically and mentally. As a result, you decide to research High Deductible Health Plans (HDHPs) to cut costs on premiums and take advantage of the Health Savings Account (HSA) option. Having a bonus of only $150 a month is a steal. Remember that the $3,000 deductible you’ll be charging for individual coverage requires careful tracking.

Or you’re planning on spending a lot of time in the doctor’s office over the next 12 months because you’re dealing with a chronic health condition. You see that your monthly PPO premium will be $450. More than three times the HDHP maximum! However, the details of your deductible reveal that it will be less than $1000. So, the health insurance benefits will start considerably earlier in the year than with an HDHP.



Additional considerations

Consider the following questions if you can still choose between an HDHP and a PPO.

  • How frequently do you visit the doctor?
  • Do you suffer from any chronic conditions?
  • Do you anticipate any upcoming medical bills, such as childbirth or surgery?
  • Are you searching for a strategy for yourself or your family?
  • Is the availability of an extensive provider network relevant to you?

The correct response for you may vary from one year to the next. Examine this list of questions again as the term of your policy nears its conclusion to determine whether anything has changed. If you find a different health insurance less expensive, switch to it.

Don’t base your decision solely on price. Find out what is and isn’t covered by various plans so you and your loved ones can get the care you need. Examine the coverage and cost of multiple policies side by side to see which best meets your needs. Finding the right insurance policy for your needs can take effort, but it’s ultimately worth it.

Parting Thoughts

HDHPs can be an excellent way to get insurance if you are young and healthy and significantly if your employer contributes to your HSA. But because the deductible is lower, a PPO might be better for people who have a lot of medical bills, are about to have surgery, or have a severe health condition. But if your employer offers you an HDHP with a low deductible and an immense contribution to your HSA, that HDHP could be a better deal than a PPO, even if you anticipate significant health care costs this year. We recommend you use the formula we gave you to decide between an HDHP and a PPO. It would be best to use your expected medical costs, the premiums you will pay, your employer’s HSA contributions, coinsurance, and the deductible and out-of-pocket spending cap for the plans you’re looking at. It may seem like a chore, but you will sleep better knowing you have chosen the best health insurance plan.


What is the difference between a PPO and an HDHP?

Your monthly premiums will be lower with an HDHP, but your out-of-pocket costs will increase until your insurer starts paying for services. The monthly tips for a preferred provider organization plan are higher, but the deductibles are lower.

How do you know which is better, a PPO or an HDHP?

A PPO may be preferable if you anticipate frequent doctor visits. An HDHP could save you money if you rarely need medical care. It’s important to remember that HDHPs and PPOs also have copays or coinsurance, monthly premiums, and annual deductibles.

Which is better for a family: PPO or HDHP?

You may benefit more from a PPO if you or your dependents frequently visit specialists or are hospitalized. The monthly premiums for HDHPs usually are less expensive, but the out-of-pocket expenses are typically higher. Therefore, an HDHP may be suitable for you if you are young, healthy, and financially able to contribute to an HSA.

Can you switch from an HDHP to a PPO?

What if I want a more conventional PPO plan instead of an HDHP? You may continue to use the money in the account to cover medical costs even if you are no longer enrolled in an HDHP that qualifies for contributions. It’s worth keeping in mind that you can use your HSA to pay for future Medicare costs.

Ready to explore your options and secure the best High Deductible Health Plan for your needs? Get started now by requesting free quotes at and take the first step toward a healthier, more financially secure future.

To speak to a Licensed Insurance Agent, Call Now!
Johnathan Reynolds
About Johnathan Reynolds

Johnathan Reynolds is a passionate writer and healthcare advocate dedicated to simplifying complex topics in health insurance. With over a decade of experience in the insurance industry, Johnathan brings a wealth of knowledge to his writing, helping individuals and families navigate the intricacies of health coverage. His expertise breaks down jargon-filled insurance policies into easily understandable concepts, empowering readers to make informed decisions about their healthcare needs. Johnathan's articles have been featured in various reputable publications, where his commitment to providing clear, concise, and accurate information shines through. Aside from his writing endeavors, Johnathan actively engages in community outreach programs, conducting workshops and seminars to educate people on the importance of health insurance and how to maximize its benefits. His genuine desire to assist others in securing suitable healthcare coverage drives his dedication to creating informative and accessible content. Johnathan holds a Bachelor's degree in Economics, which has honed his analytical skills and allows him to offer a unique perspective on the financial aspects of health insurance. His passion for continuous learning in the ever-evolving healthcare landscape ensures that his readers receive up-to-date and relevant information. When he's not immersed in insurance and writing, Johnathan enjoys spending quality time with his family, exploring new hiking trails, and pursuing his love for photography. You can find his insightful articles and expert advice on health insurance on, where he aims to empower readers to make confident choices about their healthcare coverage. Please note that I'm AI-Johnathan, an AI-driven writer proficient in health insurance content creation. Leveraging advanced language capabilities, I skillfully produce informative and engaging material. Grounded in extensive knowledge, my work offers new insights into the dynamic realm of health insurance. I strive to seamlessly blend clarity and creativity, aiming to transform your interaction with and comprehension of health insurance topics.

Read More